LNG Trading · Approx. 9 min
Why a $1.20 LNG Spread Can Lose Money: One Cargo, Costed
Buying FOB and selling DES looks like a spread. Costed line by line, one illustrative cargo loses $391,000 at a $1.20 spread, and the cash is out for six weeks before the buyer pays.
Questions this guide addresses
- How much of an FOB-to-DES price spread survives boil-off, the ship and the money tied up in the cargo?
- What sale price does one cargo need just to break even?
- How much cash must an intermediary fund before the buyer pays, and for how long?
Commercial interest PentaBay sells LNG under SPAs signed with buyers. This guide is general information and can be used without contacting us.
Method and verification scope
- PentaBay built a cargo profit-and-loss model while assessing how an intermediary could buy FOB from a Middle East-based producer and sell DES into North Asian spot demand. This article rebuilds that structure with new illustrative figures.
- No figure here is a market price, a quotation, a tender term or the result of an actual cargo. No cargo was delivered under this model. Counterparty names, tender documents, prices and financing sources are withheld; some of them are confidential.
- The arithmetic uses the same formula as the PentaBay LNG cargo margin calculator, with interest on an actual/360 basis. Public sources were used only for the general facts cited next to them.
01 · Where this comes from
Our own model said the spread was the smallest part of the answer
When PentaBay looked at reselling LNG bought FOB from a Middle East-based producer into spot demand in Korea and its neighbours, the first spreadsheet compared a purchase price with a likely sale price. The second compared every cost an intermediary carries between the loading flange and the buyer's tank. The two answers were different, and the gap between them is what this article is about.
North Asian utilities do buy single spot cargoes by public tender, priced DES: delivered at the buyer's terminal, with the seller carrying the ship, the voyage and the cargo until discharge. DES is no longer an Incoterms rule; LNG contracts define it themselves. Whoever sells DES carries every cost in the next sections. About a third of the LNG imported worldwide in 2025 was bought spot, so this is a routine calculation, not an exotic one.
02 · The worked cargo
A $1.20 spread, costed, loses $391,044
The figures below are invented for teaching and chosen to be plausible, not current. A 174,000 m³ ship loads 3.4 million MMBtu bought at $10.00 FOB and sells at $11.20 DES. That spread of $1.20 looks like $4 million. It is not.
| Line | Basis | USD |
|---|---|---|
| Sale revenue | 3,332,000 MMBtu delivered × $11.20 | 37,318,400 |
| Cargo purchase | 3,400,000 MMBtu loaded × $10.00 | −34,000,000 |
| Ship charter | 45 days × $60,000 | −2,700,000 |
| Port and canal | per cargo | −600,000 |
| Cargo insurance | per cargo | −60,000 |
| Interest on the cash gap | $34.0m × 7% × 40/360 | −264,444 |
| Standby / LC fee | $34.0m × 1.5% × 60/360 | −85,000 |
| Cargo margin | −391,044 |
Illustrative figures, not market prices. Break-even DES price on these inputs: $11.317 per MMBtu. At $11.50 the cargo earns $608,556, about $0.18 per delivered MMBtu.
03 · Boil-off
You pay for what is loaded and are paid for what arrives
LNG warms slowly in the tanks and part of it boils off. Modern ships burn that gas as fuel, which is why boil-off is easy to forget in a price comparison. For the cargo owner it is still a loss of saleable product. At 0.10% a day over 20 laden days, 68,000 MMBtu never reaches the buyer: $680,000 of cargo bought and not sold.
Use the nominated ship's guaranteed figure, not a rule of thumb. Published studies cite around 0.10–0.15% a day for large carriers, and older steam ships run higher. On our cargo at $11.50 DES, 0.08% a day leaves a $764,956 margin and 0.15% leaves $217,556. Heel retained for the return voyage and gas used to cool the tanks before loading are further adjustments the calculator leaves out.
Sources [2]
04 · The ship
Charter days include the way back
A DES seller pays for the ship for the whole round voyage it needs: positioning, loading, the laden leg, discharge and the ballast leg home, plus port waiting time. Twenty laden days can easily mean forty-five paid days. Counting only the laden leg understates freight by more than half.
Spot charter rates move faster than cargo prices. Holding everything else at the $11.50 case, the margin is $1,958,556 at $30,000 a day, $608,556 at $60,000 and a loss of $1,191,444 at $100,000. An offer priced before the ship is fixed is a bet on the charter market, whether or not the seller meant to place one.
| Charter rate, USD/day | Freight, USD | Cargo margin, USD |
|---|---|---|
| 30,000 | 1,350,000 | 1,958,556 |
| 60,000 | 2,700,000 | 608,556 |
| 100,000 | 4,500,000 | −1,191,444 |
Illustrative figures. Other inputs as in the worked cargo.
05 · The cash gap
About $37 million goes out weeks before any comes in
Producers selling FOB usually want payment secured before the cargo is loaded. Buyers taking DES usually pay after discharge, once quantity and quality at the terminal have been agreed. In between sit loading, the laden voyage, discharge and the buyer's payment period. In our model that gap was about forty days, and it is the reason a cargo can be profitable on paper and still impossible to do.
On the worked cargo the intermediary has paid out $37.36 million for cargo, ship, port and insurance before the buyer pays. Interest for forty days at 7% is $264,444; if the buyer's payment slips to seventy days, interest rises to $462,778 and the $11.50 margin falls from $608,556 to $410,222. The standby or letter of credit that secures the producer adds its own fee for as long as it is outstanding.
This is also why a first-time seller finds the spot market harder than its prices suggest. Without a delivery record, a new seller is usually asked for more security, not less, and every instrument has a cost and a credit line behind it. Our SBLC guides cover what such an instrument must say and how to check one on receipt.
06 · Before quoting
Eight things to fix before a DES price is a price
If any of these is open, quote a range and name the open item. A single figure built on guesses is the most expensive kind of offer to withdraw.
- Ship nominated and compatible with the buyer's terminal; charter rate and paid days fixed or capped.
- Ship's guaranteed boil-off rate, heel and cool-down requirements known.
- Purchase and sale prices on the same basis, or the index difference priced.
- Producer's payment date and form of security agreed.
- Buyer's payment date after discharge, and what happens if quantity or quality is disputed.
- Credit instrument issuer, amount, expiry and fee confirmed by the bank, not assumed.
- Funding line sized for the full cash out and the longest realistic gap.
- Insurance, port, canal and agency costs quoted for this voyage, not last year's.
Practical takeaways
- The buyer pays for what arrives and the seller is paid for what was loaded; boil-off is a cost before any fee is counted.
- Charter days include the ballast leg and port time. On our illustrative cargo, moving the day rate from $60,000 to $100,000 turns a $0.61 million profit into a $1.19 million loss.
- An intermediary pays out about the whole cargo value weeks before collecting. Price the interest and the credit instrument before quoting, not after winning.
- Quote a single DES price only when the ship, its boil-off rate, the payment days and the credit line are known; otherwise quote a range and say what is open.
Sources and further reading
Source titles are preserved in their original language. Figures retain the reference period stated by each source.
- International Chamber of Commerce The Incoterms® rules 2010 ↗ (opens in a new tab)
States that DAT and DAP replaced the Incoterms 2000 rules DAF, DES, DEQ and DDU. LNG contracts still use "DES" as a defined contract term.
Accessed 2026-11-21 - CE Delft LNG boil-off gas at berth (2026) ↗ (opens in a new tab)
Cites a common boil-off rate of around 0.1–0.15% a day for the tanks of large LNG carriers. Use the nominated ship's own figure.
Accessed 2026-11-21 - GIIGNL GIIGNL Annual Report (2026 edition, covering 2025) ↗ (opens in a new tab)
Reports that about 35% of LNG imported in 2025 was bought on a spot basis.
Accessed 2026-11-21 - Offshore Energy (LNG World News) South Korea's KOMIPO launches LNG cargo tender (2016) ↗ (opens in a new tab)
A public report of a Korean state-owned generator buying one spot cargo on a DES basis by tender. Used only to show that such tenders are public and priced DES.
Accessed 2026-11-21